Skip to content

menu

Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas logo
homeabout usexpertisepeoplecontact
RSS LinkedIn Facebook Instagram Spotify
Search
Close

India Corporate Law

Home » The 70% Conundrum Part II – Game Changing Directions of Haryana RERA

The 70% Conundrum Part II – Game Changing Directions of Haryana RERA

By Abhilash Pillai & Ashish Jain on July 23, 2019
Posted in Real Estate

Directions of Haryana RERA - Open 3 Bank Accounts - HRERA

Taking a cue from the Supertech Home Buyers case (as discussed in Part I of this series), the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority (HRERA) has now issued directions to promoters on opening bank accounts, titled as ‘The Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Gurugram Bank Accounts for the Registered Projects Directions, 2019’ (Directions).

The Directions discuss the opening and maintenance of bank accounts specified under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (Act) and the Haryana Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Rules, 2017 (Rules). The Directions have been issued pursuant to the powers conferred under Section 37 of the Act, which enable the HRERA to issue necessary directions from time to time to the promoters (developers) or allottees or real estate agents.

Requirement of Three Bank Accounts

Under the Directions, a promoter is required to open three bank accounts in relation to a real estate project. They are as follows:

 

3 Bank Accounts - Real Estate - HRERA

 

  1. Project’s Master Account (Master Account):

    The entire amount realised from the allottees will have to be deposited in a no-lien/ no-charge account, called the Master Account. The Directions further state that this bank account has to be free from all ‘encumbrances, lien, loan and control of any third party i.e., lender/ bank/ financial institution’. Prior permission of the HRERA is required for carrying out any change to this account. At the end of each business day, 70% of the amount lying in this Master Account must be transferred to the RERA Complaint Separate Account.

  2. RERA Complaint Separate Account (RERA Account):

    Out of the Master Account, 70% of the receivables will be deposited into a separate bank account called the RERA Account. No ‘encumbrance, lien, loan and control of any third party i.e., lender/ bank/ financial institution’ can be created over this account. The Directions clarify that no amount from this account can be utilised for re-payment or pre-payment of project loan/ facilities. Proceeds of this account can only be used for the construction and development of the project and proportionate land cost, as now defined in the Directions. The Directions permit the promoters to create ‘no-lien/ no-charge fixed deposits’ over the funds available in this account. Prior permission of the HRERA is required for carrying out any change to this account.

  3. Promoter’s Free Project Account (Free Account):

    After transferring the 70% amount from the Master Account, the remaining 30% of the receivables will be deposited in a bank account called the Free Account. The loan amount availed for developing a project and the interest to be paid on the said loan amount can be paid from the funds available in the Free Account. The amount available in this bank account can also be used for business activities related to the same project if the HRERA has not issued any instructions to the contrary to the Promoter.

The requirement for maintaining three bank accounts is something that has been introduced by the Directions. It also mandates that the amount to be deposited in the RERA Account should exclude pass-through charges and indirect taxes without clarifying where such amount has to be deposited. We understand that the said payments, which are to be made by the promoter, cannot be made directly from the Master Account as there is a restriction that any transfer from the Master Account can only be made to the other two accounts.  Hence, there is no clarity on this point in the Directions.

Charge on the Accounts

After the Supertech Homebuyers Case, HRERA has brought in these Directions which states that a charge/ lien cannot be created on the RERA Account.

Similarly, no charge/ lien can be created on the Master Account. Further, any withdrawal/ transfer from the Master Account can only be made either to the RERA Account or to the Free Account. The banking institutions are directed to ensure that no withdrawal is carried out from the Master Account except to the RERA Account or to the Free Account.

The Directions have gone further and created more accounts, which were not mandated either in the Act or the Rules.

Complications in Operating the Free Account

Under the Act and the Rules, there were no guidelines on the usage of the 30% of receivables which are left with the promoters after depositing the mandated 70% of receivables under the RERA Account. However, the Directions have imposed restrictions on free usage of that money by the promoter and have provided that the money in the Free Account can only be utilised for ‘Business Activities related to the same project’ and cannot be utilized for any other project of the promoter. Such a condition certainly removes the free nature of the Free Account.

Retention of the Estimated Cost of the Project

Another interesting condition that the Directions has introduced is that if the estimated cost of a project is higher than the estimated amount of total receivables at any stage, then 100% of the funds lying in this account must be transferred to the RERA Complaint Separate Account, as long as this condition exists. The Act and the Rules do not mandate any such condition on the promoter. During the commencement of the project, the amount of receivables received is bound to be less than the estimated cost of the project as 100% of the flats cannot be sold at the onset of the real estate project. Hence, all the receivables will have to be deposited in the RERA Account from the Master Account.

There is also no clarification as to how this will work with the necessary certifications, which are required for withdrawing any amount from the RERA Account, as once the mismatch ends, 30% of the receivables will have to be deposited back in the FREE Account. With the introduction of such a condition on the promoters’ cash-strapped sector, this will worsen the liquidity crisis.

Challenge or Opportunity?

The Directions impose manifold restrictions on promoters, many of which are not provided either in the Act or the Rules. They are expected to be challenged, therefore, before a court of law sooner or later. While HRERA can argue that the Directions have been brought in to protect the rights of homebuyers and to reduce cases like Supertech Homebuyers, they will have to prove a lot more in the court of law to save these Directions from being scrapped.

*The authors were assisted by Siddhant S, Associate. 


 

Tags: Haryana Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Rules 2017, Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority (HRERA), HRERA, RERA Account
Print:
Email this postTweet this postLike this postShare this post on LinkedIn
Photo of Abhilash Pillai Abhilash Pillai

Partner in the real estate practice at the Bangalore office of Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas. Abhilash has experience in advising real estate funds, multi-national companies, lenders, borrowers, retailers, institutional and non-institutional real estate investors, developers and operators in a broad range of business arena.…

Partner in the real estate practice at the Bangalore office of Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas. Abhilash has experience in advising real estate funds, multi-national companies, lenders, borrowers, retailers, institutional and non-institutional real estate investors, developers and operators in a broad range of business arena.

His practice areas include advising on all aspects of investments into real estate projects, creation of security, sale and purchase of real properties, including commercial leasing, due diligence, structuring, negotiation and documentation of the transaction, drafting and negotiating agreements relating to sale, mortgage, loans, license, construction, services, agency & franchise, litigation and arbitration related to real properties, among many others and advising domestic and international corporate clients on their general legal requirements.

Abhilash has been recognized in 2014 by the Legal 500 Asia Pacific India Guide to Law Firms. He can be reached at abhilash.pillai@cyrilshroff.com

Read more about Abhilash Pillai
Show more Show less
Photo of Ashish Jain Ashish Jain

Partner in the Real Estate Practice at the Delhi office of Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas. Ashish has over eleven years of experience in the Real Estate Sector. His areas of work within the sector extend to conveyancing, development of mixed used projects, redevelopment projects…

Partner in the Real Estate Practice at the Delhi office of Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas. Ashish has over eleven years of experience in the Real Estate Sector. His areas of work within the sector extend to conveyancing, development of mixed used projects, redevelopment projects, warehouse and logistics, retail and hospitality. In addition to the above, he also advises on real estate aspects of corporate and financing transactions in sectors such as construction and development, special economic zones, power, cement, and many more. He can be reached at ashish.jain@cyrilshroff.com

Show more Show less
Related Posts
Relief to Affected Home Buyers For Delay In Possession
Relief to Affected Home Buyers For Delay In Possession
June 20, 2022
NOIDA stands in the shoes of an operational creditor
NOIDA stands in the shoes of an operational creditor
June 8, 2022
No Occupancy Certificate No Maintenance Charges
No Occupancy Certificate: No Maintenance Charges
May 25, 2022

Stay Connected

RSS LinkedIn Facebook Instagram Spotify
Subscribe to this Blog

Blog Authors Show/Hide

  • Cyril Shroff
  • Aakriti Singh
  • Rishav Dixit
  • Rohil Deshpande
  • Rohan Priyadarshi
  • Rohan Jain
  • Robin Grover
  • Ritu Sajnani
  • Ritika Rathi
  • Rishi Ray
  • Rishabh Malaviya
  • Rishabh Shroff
  • Rinkel Singh
  • Richa Roy
  • Richa Mohanty Rao
  • Ria Lulla
  • Reuben Chacko
  • Ravisha Seth
  • Ravindra Bandhakavi
  • Ravi Shah
  • Rohit Tiwari
  • Ruchi Bawa
  • Rashmi Pradeep
  • Sanchit Garg
  • Sara Sundaram
  • Sapna Raskar
  • Santosh Janakiram
  • Sanskriti Sidana
  • Sanjana Rao
  • Saniya Mirani
  • Sanika Gokhale
  • Sandeep Dave
  • Sana Ahmed
  • Ruchira Shroff
  • Samiksha Pednekar
  • Samhita Mehra
  • Sameer Bindra
  • Saloni Kapadia
  • Saloni Jain
  • Rupal Jaiswal
  • Ruetveij Pandya
  • Raunak Dhillon
  • Saurav Samaddar
  • Neha Samant
  • Nooreen Haider
  • Nivedita Rao
  • Nishtha Gupta
  • Nishkarsh Jakhar
  • Nikita Swamy
  • Nikhilesh Barik
  • Nihaad Dewan
  • Neha Shivhare
  • Navin Kumar
  • Pallavi Rao
  • Namrata Kolar
  • Naimi Kamdar
  • Nagavalli G
  • Mukul Sharma
  • Mreganka Kukreja
  • Omar Ahmad
  • Paridhi Adani
  • Ramya Chandrasekhar
  • Priya Gupta
  • Ramgovind Kuruppath
  • Ramanuj Kumar
  • Rajalakshmi Natarajan
  • Rahul Maheshwari
  • Rahul Dave
  • Punya Khachi
  • Priyal Modi
  • Pritvish Shetty
  • Parikalp Gupta
  • Pranjita Barman
  • Pranay Bagdi
  • Prakhar Pandey
  • Pragati Sharma
  • Prafful Goyal
  • Poornima Singh
  • Pooja Patel
  • Pooja Chatterjee
  • P.K. Bagga
  • Satyadarshi Kunal
  • Shalaka Patil
  • Mohanakrishna.C
  • Tanya Nayyar
  • Vaidehi Chande
  • Utkarsh Bhatnagar
  • Umang Pathak
  • Uday Khare
  • Tuhin Dey
  • Trayosha Darapuneni
  • Tarun Agarwal
  • Tanya Singh
  • Tanvi Kishore
  • Vanshika Mohta
  • Tanvi Kini
  • Tanusree Banerjee
  • TantuVardhn S
  • Tanmay Patnaik
  • Taher D Mandviwala
  • Swaha Sinha
  • Swagata Ghosh
  • Suvojit Halder
  • Vandana Sekhri
  • Varsha Yogish
  • Surya Rajkumar
  • Vishesh Bhatia
  • Yashvi Ganeriwal
  • Yash Vardhan
  • Yash Lahoty
  • Yash Johri
  • Yash Jain
  • Yash J. Ashar
  • Vivek Rathore
  • Vivaik Sharma
  • Vineet Unnikrishnan
  • Varun Kannan
  • Vineet Bhansali
  • Vinay Sirohia
  • Vinamrata Shrivastava
  • Vikram Shah
  • Vijay Parthasarathi
  • Vidya Sunderam
  • Vidhi Sarin
  • Vasujith Ram
  • Varun Mehta
  • Surya Sambyal
  • Surbhi Ajitsaria
  • Shalini Singh
  • Shrey Srivastava
  • Siddhant Sattur
  • Siddhant Sharma
  • Shweta Sharma
  • Shuchita Choudhry
  • Shubhankar Jain
  • Shreya Teewari
  • Shreya Bansal
  • Shree Sinha
  • Siddharth Iyer
  • Shivanshu Bhardwaj
  • Shikha Tandon
  • Shavya Kumbhat
  • Shatrajit Banerji
  • Sharan Kukreja
  • Sharada Ramachandra
  • Shaneen Parikh
  • Siddharth Anand
  • Siddharth Ratho
  • Surajkumar Shetty
  • Sreetama Sen
  • Surabhi Saboo
  • Surabhi Khattar
  • Supriya Aakulu
  • Sucheta Bhattacharya
  • Subhojit Sadhu
  • Srishti Aishwarya
  • Srinivas Chatti
  • Srideepa Bhattacharyya
  • S.R. Patnaik
  • Simran Aggarwal
  • Spandan Biswal
  • Soumyadipta Chanda
  • Soumya Dasgupta
  • Sophia Mustafa
  • Sonakshi Arora
  • Smruti Shah
  • Sindhushri Badarinath
  • Sindhu Rao
  • Simran Khorana
  • Simran Jain
  • Molla Hasan
  • Mitakshi Lakhani
  • Mohammed Bengali
  • Arun Goswami
  • Arnav Shah
  • Arjun Sreenivas
  • Arjun Goswami
  • Archit Bhatnagar
  • Aravind Raj
  • Apoorv Jain
  • Anushka Shah
  • Ashish Jain
  • Anushka Jain
  • Anuradha Mukherjee
  • Anuj Prasad
  • Anu Tiwari
  • Anshu Choudhary
  • Ankoosh Mehta
  • Ankita Ray
  • Ankit Namdeo
  • Arun Prabhu
  • Ashlesha Mittal
  • Anirud Sudarsan R
  • Bharath Reddy
  • CAM Disputes Team
  • CAM Corporate Team
  • CAM Competition Team
  • Bishwajit Dubey
  • Bishen Jeswant
  • Bipluv Jhingan
  • Biplab Lenin
  • Bharath Sridhar
  • Bharat Vasani
  • Ashutosh Singh
  • Bhakti Madan
  • Bhadra Nair
  • Ayushi Singhal
  • Aviral Sahai
  • Aviral Chauhan
  • Avinash Umapathy
  • Avinash Das
  • Avani Dalal
  • Astha Tambi
  • Ashwin Sapra
  • Anjaneya Das
  • Anirban Mohapatra
  • CAM Markets Team
  • Abhishek Khatri
  • Aditya Prasad
  • Aditya Mehta
  • Aditya Marwah
  • Aditya Jindal
  • Aditi Thakur
  • Aditi Misra
  • Adarsh Saxena
  • Abhishek Sharma
  • Abhinav Kumar
  • Aditya Sikka
  • Abhinav Rawat
  • Abhilasha Malpani
  • Abhilash Pillai
  • Abhijeet Shinde
  • Abhijeet Das
  • Abe Abraham
  • Aayushi Bindal
  • Aashima Johur
  • Aarushi Bansal
  • Aditya Sarkar
  • Aishwaria Ramanan
  • Animesh Bisht
  • Amita Katragadda
  • Aniket Singhania
  • Anchal Dhir
  • Ananya Pandit
  • Anandita Kaushik
  • Anand Jayachandran
  • Anand Deshpande
  • Amit H Wadhwani
  • Ajay Sawhney
  • Amey Pathak
  • Ambika Sahai
  • Aman Singhania
  • Aman Chandola
  • Alice George
  • Akshay Zaveri
  • Akshat Sahajpal
  • Akshat Razdan
  • Akila Agrawal
  • Ajo Jomy
  • CAM Finance Team
  • CAM Projects Team
  • Aakriti Thakur
  • Kaushalya Madhavan
  • Kritika Sethi
  • Kriti Srivastava
  • Krithika Radhakrishnan
  • Kranti Mohan
  • Komal Gupta
  • King Dungerwal
  • Khyati G
  • Ketaki Mehta
  • Kaveri Varma
  • Kartik Prasad
  • Kartik Jain
  • Karthik Koragal
  • Karan Khanna
  • Kapil Arora
  • Kamalika Bhattacharjee
  • Kamakshi Puri
  • Jyoti Dastidar
  • Kunal Gopal
  • Kush Wadehra
  • Jinal Mehta
  • Maitrayi Jain
  • Misha Patel
  • Megha Krishnamurthi
  • Meeta Kurpad
  • Manu Varghese
  • Mansi Mantoo
  • Mansi Birla
  • Manasvi Nandu
  • Maheshwari Sundaresh
  • L. Viswanathan
  • Madhavi Khanna
  • Madhav Kanoria
  • M Shivraman
  • Lvanika Parti
  • Lily Vadera
  • Leena Chacko
  • Lakshmi Prakash
  • Jeeta Nayak
  • CAM Tax Team
  • Divya Behl
  • Ganesh Kumar
  • Ganesh Gopalakrishnan
  • Gagan Sharma
  • Faraz Alam Sagar
  • Faiza Khan
  • Esha Sanas
  • Esha Himadri
  • Drishti Das
  • Divya Laxman
  • Gaurav Gupte
  • Dhruv Singhal
  • Dhananjay Kumar
  • Devyani Singh
  • Devanshi Dalal
  • Devaki Mankad
  • Deepjoyika Dastidar
  • Chinar Gupta
  • Chandana Arval
  • Gathi Prakash
  • Gauri Rasgotra
  • Jeet Shroff
  • Indranath Bishnu
  • Jayati Vyas
  • Jasmine Latkar
  • Jashaswi Ghosh
  • Janvi Manek
  • Janhavi Seksaria
  • Janhavi Manohar
  • Janak Panicker
  • Ishita Khandelwal
  • Indranil Deshmukh
  • Ifrah Shaikh
  • Gautam Gandotra
  • Hiral Motta
  • Himaa Sudhir
  • Harmeet Dhall
  • Harish Sekar
  • Gyanendra Kumar
  • Guest Author
  • Gokul Rajan
  • George Varghese
  • Gazal Rawal

Firm Blogs

  • Competition Law
  • India Tax Law
  • Private Client

Stay Connected

RSS LinkedIn Facebook Instagram Spotify

Topics

Archives

Recent Updates

  • FIG Paper (No. 13) – RBI guidance on loading of PPIs through credit lines
  • Awarding Interest on Interest: A three Judge Bench of the Supreme Court Upholds the Law
  • SEBI Clarifies Applicability of Portfolio Managers Regulations to an Indian Manager of an Offshore Fund
  • Pharmaceutical and Healthcare Industry: A Case for Regulation Through Blockchain
  • Relief to Affected Home Buyers For Delay In Possession
Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas logo
  • home
  • about us
  • expertise
  • people
  • contact
  • disclaimer
  • privacy policy

Follow Us

RSS LinkedIn Facebook Instagram Spotify
Copyright ©2022, Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas. All Rights Reserved.
Law blog design & platform by LexBlog LexBlog Logo